Today we’d like to introduce you to Lamar Rutherford.
Lamar, we appreciate you taking the time to share your story with us today. Where does your story begin?
From Bagels to Boardrooms: A Life of Unexpected Adventures
Tell us your story. How did you get to where you are today?
I’ve had a rather unconventional career, although I suppose that depends on how you define conventional. I’ve been a CPA, a bagel shop owner, a corporate executive, a yoga studio owner, a college instructor, a business broker, a strategic advisor, and a novelist. Somewhere along the way, I’ve also managed to play polo in India, Dubai, and Morocco, learn and perform Argentine tango, and travel to some extraordinary places.
Apparently, I’ve never been particularly good at sticking to one career. Or turning down an interesting opportunity.
I started my career as a CPA with Arthur Andersen in Boston. It was a terrific education in business, but I soon realized that I was more interested in running companies than auditing them.
There was just one problem. I didn’t know anything about running a business.
So I decided to learn.
I quit Arthur Andersen and took a job at a bagel shop where I used to buy lunch. I’d never worked in a restaurant, but I figured the best way to learn was from behind the counter.
Imagine the surprise of my former colleagues when they stopped in for breakfast and found their former CPA serving bagels.
They probably thought I’d had a spectacular career setback. Little did they know I had a plan.
Eventually, I moved back to Seattle and opened my own bagel shop, The Bagel Stop. It was my first entrepreneurial adventure, and it taught me more about running a business than I could ever have learned from an audit.
While living in Seattle, I also wanted to find a way to give back to the community, so I joined the board of Head Start, a wonderful organization supporting disadvantaged preschool children and their families.
One experience in particular stayed with me.
I was talking with a volunteer whose family had recently immigrated legally from Columbia to join relatives in the United States. She had been a lawyer in Columbia, and her husband had been a doctor. But because of different professional licensing and training requirements, neither could practice their profession here without essentially starting over.
They were both over 40, and retraining wasn’t a simple proposition. So he was working as a taxi driver, and she was helping care for children in daycare. Two highly educated, accomplished people doing whatever they could to support their family.
It made a lasting impression on me.
Most people want the opportunity to support themselves and their families through their own work. Employment provides far more than a paycheck. It creates independence, dignity, stability, and opportunity.
That experience helped shape my belief in the importance of small businesses and the jobs they create.
This became a thread running through much of my career.
After opening The Bagel Stop, I earned my MBA at Dartmouth’s Tuck School of Business. I worked in brand management for Nestlé and Disney, then jumped into the early internet industry as VP of Marketing for CitySearch, helping launch the company into nine cities in one year.
But the entrepreneurial bug never went away.
After CitySearch, I opened two yoga studios in Los Angeles, which I eventually sold to YogaWorks. Along the way, I also worked on marketing and strategy for companies including Hunt-Wesson and Intuit. After selling the yoga business, I continued working in marketing and strategy on a global scale with Orient-Express, now Belmond.
I moved to San Diego in 2010, where I spent eight years teaching entrepreneurship at UC San Diego’s Rady School of Management.
I loved helping students explore new ideas and think about turning them into viable businesses. It also reinforced something I’d learned through my own adventures: starting a business is hard. Keeping it successful can be even harder.
While teaching, I began working in business brokerage and mergers and acquisitions, helping entrepreneurs buy existing companies and helping owners sell businesses they’d spent years building.
Today, through Excellens Solutions, I still help business owners prepare for successful transitions, increase the value of their companies, and find buyers who can carry those businesses forward.
I’m also a Vistage Chair, coaching and facilitating peer advisory groups for CEOs and key executives. I love working with business leaders, helping them solve difficult problems, challenge assumptions, and discover new possibilities.
In many ways, it’s all connected to that experience with Head Start years ago.
Successful small businesses create jobs, support families, and strengthen communities. When an owner retires, I’d much rather see that business passed on to someone who can continue growing it than watch it close its doors.
What has motivated you to take so many different paths?
This actually goes back to something that happened when I was in high school.
Another student did something that embarrassed me terribly. Looking back, I realize he was probably just flirting, although at the time I certainly didn’t appreciate his technique.
But the experience got me thinking.
I realized that many of the moments we remember most vividly are the ones when we’re uncomfortable, challenged, excited, or even a little frightened.
We remember winning or losing a tennis tournament, earning an award we worked hard for, struggling with something difficult, or taking a chance when we weren’t sure how things would turn out.
We don’t tend to remember all those perfectly ordinary Tuesdays when nothing much happened.
I came to a conclusion that’s influenced my life ever since: If the experiences we remember most are the ones that challenge us, why not deliberately seek out more of them?
That philosophy has led me to move to new cities, start businesses in industries I knew little about, travel around the world, play polo in places like India and Dubai, learn and perform tango, and write a fiction novel.
Some of those experiences have been exhilarating. Others have been humbling. A few have made me question my judgment. But almost all of them have made for good stories.
And sometimes those are the best adventures.
What are you working on now?
I’m preparing to launch a new book called I’m Going to Sell My Business for Millions… What Could Possibly Go Wrong?
After more than 15 years helping owners buy and sell businesses, I’ve accumulated quite a collection of stories.
Selling a business can be one of the most important financial decisions an entrepreneur ever makes. It’s also one of the most emotional.
I’ve seen owners work themselves nearly to death trying to maximize profits, only to discover they’ve made their companies almost impossible to sell. I’ve seen people insist their businesses are worth millions because that’s what they need to retire, regardless of what the financial statements suggest.
And I’ve seen deals nearly fall apart over issues that nobody in their right mind would have imagined could become deal-breakers.
Some of these situations are funny, some are frustrating, and some are heartbreaking.
After watching hundreds of entrepreneurs navigate the process of selling their businesses, I concluded that somebody needed to write down these stories, might as well be me.
I wanted to write a book that would entertain business owners while helping them avoid costly mistakes. There are plenty of technical books about valuations and due diligence. Mine focuses on the human side of buying and selling businesses.
I’m also continuing my work with Excellens Solutions and Vistage, helping business owners and executives build stronger companies and make better decisions.
And because apparently I don’t have enough projects, I’ve started experimenting with a new creative endeavor called The Chapeau Series.
I take photographs of friends wearing hats and then transform the images into personalized portraits, creating custom backgrounds, frames, and sometimes modifying the hats or wardrobe to reflect each person’s personality, interests, or profession.
It’s part photography, part design, part technology, and a lot of creative experimentation. But so fun!
What role does creativity play in your life?
I’ve always enjoyed finding creative solutions, whether I’m working on a business problem or something entirely unrelated.
In business, creativity isn’t necessarily about artistic talent. It’s about looking at a situation from a different perspective and seeing possibilities that others might overlook.
Sometimes the best solution to a problem is something nobody initially considered.
That same curiosity led me to write my first novel, CodeY, an international action-adventure thriller involving genetic matchmaking, romance, and a terrorist conspiracy.
Writing fiction was a wonderful change from analyzing financial statements and negotiating business transactions. Although, after years in business brokerage, I can tell you that real life occasionally produces characters and situations that would be rejected by a fiction editor as too unbelievable.
I’m working on the sequel to CodeY, so maybe some of those real-life stories will slip into the next book.
The Chapeau Series is my latest creative playground. It’s a combination of photography, design, technology, and occasionally discovering that the hat my friend chose is exactly what makes the portrait work.
I think creativity encourages experimentation, taking chances, and occasionally making a complete mess of something before figuring out how to make it work.
Which, come to think of it, is also a pretty good description of entrepreneurship.
What do you find most rewarding about your work?
I enjoy helping people see possibilities they might not have recognized on their own.
Sometimes that means helping a CEO solve a difficult leadership problem. Sometimes it’s helping an entrepreneur recognize a promising business opportunity. And sometimes it’s helping an owner realize that the company they’ve spent decades building can be sold successfully, providing financial security for the owner while allowing the business and its employees to continue thriving.
That last part is particularly meaningful to me.
When a business closes, it’s not just the owner who is affected. Employees lose jobs, suppliers lose customers, and communities lose an important contributor.
Helping businesses succeed and survive creates more opportunities for people to work, contribute, and build better lives.
That’s a pretty good reason to get up in the morning.
What would you like people to know about you?
I think life is much more interesting when you’re willing to try new things, even when, or maybe especially when, you’re not particularly good at them yet.
I’ve learned that you don’t have to be an expert before you begin. Sometimes you just need enough curiosity to get started and enough determination to keep going.
I’ve also learned not to take myself too seriously. Business can be stressful, things don’t always go according to plan, and the more you can laugh at yourself or with others, the better.
I’ve been fortunate enough to have many opportunities to try different things, keep learning, and explore new interests.
There are still places I want to visit, things I want to learn, people I want to meet, and probably a few businesses or creative projects I haven’t even thought of yet.
I’ve come to believe that the best experiences in life often begin just outside your comfort zone. So I plan to keep exploring, keep learning, and hopefully collect a few more good stories along the way.
I’m sure it wasn’t obstacle-free, but would you say the journey has been fairly smooth so far?
Is it ever a “smooth road”? Here’s an article I wrote on one of the biggest challenges I faced.
Working with “Crazy
How many of you have worked with someone who, after they left your life, it felt like a wrecking ball had come through? We’ve all had some wonderful, shall we say “learning opportunities”.
Here’s a story for you.
A woman was approached by a man to be his business partner. He was charming, handsome, talented, and an excellent instructor. Since this was a business in the health industry that she was passionate about, she decided to get involved. She noticed some red flags with him, but she had worked with difficult people so she thought she could manage it. And she made sure that she was 65% owner, so she had control, right?
However, challenges arose quickly. If another instructor started to do well, he would change their schedule and undermine their success. He couldn’t have another instructor outshine him. As you can imagine, this was not great for business. It limits your growth when your lead instructor sabotages how well the other instructors can build their classes.
Unfortunately, things got even worse. She started hearing reports of him sexually harassing and injuring students. One friend jokingly remarked after attending his class, “I think I might be pregnant”. On top of this, he started stealing from the business.
Realizing her money and her assets were at risk, she faced a difficult truth: despite being passionate and her desire to do good for the customers, she simply could not continue under these circumstances. She attempted to resolve the issues. She tried logic, reasoning, the silent treatment, yelling, screaming, even getting his wife and mom involved, whatever she could to get him to stop the inappropriate behavior. But in his mind, these things didn’t happen. It wasn’t his reality. He was a narcissist. Narcissists can’t be wrong. Their egos simply don’t allow it. They recreate reality and believe their own version. That’s why it is so hard to read a narcissist for what they are, because they believe what they are saying, even if it’s completely unrelated to the truth.
Here’s a description of a narcissist I think is helpful. “When you are on the other side of an argument with a narcissist, you enter a dangerous territory where human decency does not exist. Narcissists see themselves as the winner of every argument. They see you as the loser. You are always wrong. They fail to recognize the actual reality and inherent truth of the situation. There’s no truth, no forgiveness, and no admission of guilt. It’s Russia versus Ukraine, and you are Ukraine.”
Once she realized the situation was not going to improve, she had to do something. She decided to fire him and his wife—both instructors at the studio—who accounted for about 50% of her volume. With $12,000 in rent payments looming over her every month, she knew losing this volume would be painful.
She knew firing him would be messy, but what unfolded turned out to be worse than she could have imagined; it felt like a bad movie, the lengths he went to harm her and the business were so unbelievable. He had people stand outside the studio with signs denouncing the business. He called all of their instructors and employees—sometimes even their parents—spreading lies about her. He deceived the bank so they closed the businesses account, right after she wrote payroll checks, forcing her to write personal checks to all the employees instead. He sent out mailers filled with more lies to their customers. All of this was illegal.
His last words to her were chilling: “You better watch your step, you stupid fucking bitch”. For safety, she had her mom come and stay with her. At one point, he even attempted to have her mother arrested on trumped-up trespassing charges. While these actions were clearly unlawful, how could she stop him? She was already stretched thin trying to keep the business afloat by covering shifts left by departing staff and communicating to customers that the business was still viable. It was rough.
So, this is my story – my business partner was my life’s wrecking ball. I was exhausted from covering all the hours – the studio opened at 6 AM and closed after 8 PM – and so stressed I felt sick. I knew I had to fix this mess. And, of all things, this was a yoga business.
Faced with leases that could not be abandoned, I did my best to practice what we preach in yoga. I turned inward – self-reflection, meditation, and even a little prayer – although I don’t adhere to any particular religion; I believe in my version of God or universal spirit.
Three key realizations emerged from this process:
1. Clarity on legal action. Should I pursue legal action against him? Pursuing him legally, regardless of the outcome would mean enduring at least another year of emotional turmoil. He had no assets so, best case I would win the suit and possibly protect someone else from falling prey to his narcissistic behavior.
After much reflection, I chose not to do this but instead focus on disentangling myself from our business relationship as quickly as possible and simply accept any related financial losses.
2. Clarity on the business. The second choice was whether to close the business today or continue to slog through this mess and try to turn it around. Several times, after I fired him, customers had come in and yelled at me, telling me how awful I was for letting him go. They didn’t know all that he had been doing so they thought he was charming and wonderful. It wasn’t necessarily their fault, but it was difficult to be in that position.
I prayed for some kind of sign on this. The next day a woman came into the studio. Whether you believe in any kind of God or not, it was an interesting coincidence. She and her husband had also gotten into business with my partner, an Indian restaurant downstairs. I was sure she was going to yell at me for what I had done as well, but instead, she walked up to me and gave me a big hug and said, “Hang in there. He’s doing the same things to me that he’s done to you.” Apparently, they were also struggling to work with him and he was berating and belittling her. Decision made, I stayed in business.
3. Compassion. The third thing that came up was compassion. Through meditation, I began to feel compassion for him despite his behavior. As much as he was doing horrible things to me, he could not help being who he is and living a life where you can never be wrong, where you have to undermine and put down others to prove you’re right or better – that’s not an easy life.
This realization was a relief. I could see him clearly, forgive him, forgive myself and move on.
What are the learnings, the takeaways from an experience like this?
We are stronger and more resilient than we ever imagined. Narcissists will attack your weaknesses as a means of elevating themselves; however, it’s merely to protect their egos. Not a true reflection on you. Everyone has flaws, but we are still all perfect in our own way.
People have short memories; just a year later, my customers claimed mine was the best yoga studio with an incredible vibe.
Some individuals cannot change; you don’t have to work with or even be around those who are unhealthy for you. Life is too short to work with “crazy”. If you see red flags, move on quickly instead of trying to “make it work.”
How did my story end?
Fortunately for me, one of his wealthy private customers loaned him her attorneys. It turns out attorneys don’t like to work with “crazy” either, thus are deal got wrapped up swiftly. Remember that couple who partnered with him in the Indian restaurant? They lost their home because he used a poor attorney that time and it took years to sort out their mess.
A year later, with support from some fantastic staff who stood by me, we turned the business around. It was up over 30% from where it had been before firing him.
I also continue to help clients in similar situations find a clear path to get free from their “crazy” or navigate difficult situations. As painful as the journey was, it turned out to be a very empowering lesson.
Are there any apps, books, podcasts, blogs or other resources you think our readers should check out?
I use LinkedIn more than any other social app. My favorite podcast is Tim Ferris, but I also recently discovered All In. I love such a wide range of books. I mostly read fiction, but I love historical fiction. I loved reading books on Genghis Khan, Churchill, and Ataturk. Shantaram was a fascinating adventure, Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow and The Hunger Games series were fun reads. I recently read The Decision Maker by Dennis Bakke and recommended that to some of my CEOs.
Pricing:
- Coaching – I typically customize my coaching to suit my clients, but its usually based on a monthly retainer
- Business brokering commissions depend on the size of the deal. Bigger deals have lower commissions.
- We do BOVs (Broker’s Opinion of Value) for $3k. This includes giving owners insight on how ready they are to take their business to market.
Contact Info:
- Website: https://www.excellenssolutions.com/ and https://www.lamarrutherford.com/.
- Instagram: tolamar
- Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/lamarrutherford1 and https://www.facebook.com/ExcellensSolutions/
- LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/lamarrutherford/
- Twitter: https://x.com/toLamar and https://x.com/excellens01
- Other: https://www.linkedin.com/search/results/all/



